The Fair and Open Competition Act would prevent federal agencies and recipients of federal assistance from requiring contractors to sign an anti-competitive and costly project labor agreement (PLA) as a condition of winning a federal or federally assisted construction contract. It also would eliminate discriminatory PLA preference policies that discourage competition and may result in needless delays, waste and favoritism during the procurement of taxpayer-funded construction projects.

A PLA is a collective bargaining agreement unique to the construction industry that typically requires companies to agree to recognize unions as the representatives of their employees on that job; use the union hiring hall to obtain workers; follow union work rules; and pay into union benefit and multi-employer pension plans that nonunion employees will be unlikely to access. This forces employers to pay “double benefits” into existing plans and union plans, and it places them at a significant competitive disadvantage. In addition, PLAs typically force construction workers to pay union dues or join a union if they want to work on a PLA project and receive benefits.

When mandated by government agencies, PLAs can interfere with existing union collective bargaining agreements and unfairly discourage competition from nonunion contractors and their employees, who comprise 86.1 percent of the U.S. private construction workforce.

President Obama’s Feb. 6, 2009, Executive Order 13502 encourages federal agencies to require PLAs on federal construction projects exceeding $25 million in total cost on a case-by-case basis “in order to promote the economy and efficiency in federal procurement.”

However, studies found PLA mandates increase the cost of construction between 12 percent and 18 percent compared to similar non-PLA projects. Recent government-mandated PLAs on federal and federally assisted projects have resulted in litigation, reduced competition, increased costs, needless delays and poor hiring outcomes for minorities, women, veterans and local workers not affiliated with unions. Simply put, taxpayers are getting less and paying more when PLA preferences and mandates are required during the procurement of federal and federally assisted construction projects.

Likewise, the Obama executive order and related FAR regulations have exposed agency procurement officials to intense political pressure from special interest groups and politicians to mandate PLAs on federal and federally assisted projects even when they are not appropriate.

The Fair and Open Competition Act seeks to counteract potential special interest favoritism by prohibiting federal agencies and recipients of federal assistance from mandating PLAs and implementing PLA preferences. However, this legislation would allow federal agencies to award contracts to businesses that voluntarily enter into PLAs before or after a fair and open competitive bidding process, a common industry practice permitted by the National Labor Relations Act. 

Supported by:

  • American Council of Engineering Companies (ACEC)
  • Associated Builders and Contractors (ABC)
  • Associated General Contractors (AGC)
  • Business Coalition for Fair Competition (BCFC)
  • Construction Industry Round Table (CIRT)
  • Electronic Security Association (ESA)
  • Independent Electrical Contractors (IEC)
  • National Association of Home Builders (NAHB)
  • National Association of Women in Construction (NAWIC)
  • National Black Chamber of Commerce (NBCC)
  • National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB)
  • Small Business & Entrepreneurship Council (SBEC)
  • U.S. Chamber of Commerce

SVO POSITION: SUPPORT

STATUS: Pending Introduction

For more information, please click here.

Questions? Please contact Victor Cuauhtémoc Gomez, Sr. Director of Public Policy at victorg@thesvo.com

Stay in the know. Subscribe to our monthly Public Policy newsletter here.

More Posts

You Might Also Like

COVID 19 Resource Center
Preparing for the New Order: Submit Updated Social Distancing Protocols
As of July 7th, Santa Clara County’s latest health order amending the way businesses are allowed to operate under the Covid-19 pandemic has now been approved by the state to take effect Monday, July 13 after at first being rejected over the weekend by California officials. There are some important things all businesses need to know in order to open or continue their operations.
Jul 10, 2020
The Silicon Valley Organization
Public Policy & Advocacy
Accountability & Better Government Reforms – Rules Committee Agenda Item G.9
San José is the 10th largest city in the United States, yet it is stuck in the 1980’s with a management structure more suited for small cities. In times of crisis, we need government to be nimble, responsive, and accountable to the community for results and to bring local government into the 21st century. As we face the greatest series of crises in our lifetime – a global pandemic and the deepest economic recession since the great recession – we must have the people’s choice, an elected Accountable Mayor, be directly responsible for the city.
Jun 23, 2020
The Silicon Valley Organization
COVID 19 Resource Center
San Jose Al Fresco: Things to Know Before Setting Up Outside!
As of June 5th, San Jose Al Fresco is in full swing allowing businesses to utilize sidewalks to conduct business during shelter-in-place. The City of San Jose is now accepting applications, and it's FREE to apply! Once your application is submitted, you will be able to start utilizing the space in front of your business immediately, as long as you meet the terms and conditions described in the application. We put together some simple FAQ's about how you can participate in San Jose Al Fresco, and all the thing you need to know before applying!
Jun 16, 2020
The Silicon Valley Organization
Press Releases
Southwest Launches Sale, Extends Open Middle Seat, And Adds Health Declaration For Customers
Southwest announced their plans to keep middle seats open through at least September 30, reinforced its face mask policy and added another layer of confidence for travelers by requiring Customers to complete a Health Declaration prior to traveling. As Customers begin to travel again, Southwest also launched a sale offering low domestic fares starting at $49 one-way to select destinations today through June 18, 2020, 11:59 p.m., CDT.
Jun 16, 2020
Southwest Airlines
Press Releases
The Silicon Valley Organization Grieves Loss of Karolyn Kirchgesler
The Silicon Valley Organization (The SVO), along with our friends at Team San Jose and the community at large, are mourning the recent passing of Karolyn Kirchgesler.
Jun 15, 2020
The Silicon Valley Organization
COVID 19 Resource Center
FAQs: Reopening your business after shelter-in-place featuring Berliner Cohen
Q&A's from SVO member, Berliner Cohen's 6/3/2020 presentation
Jun 15, 2020
The Silicon Valley Organization
Explore ALl Posts
Follow Us

We’re on Instagram