Hospital contracts unfairly discriminates against arbitration agreements and subjects businesses to costly litigation. The arbitration provisions in SB 538 undermines the national policy favoring arbitration and freedom to contract for arbitration, violate the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA), and deny businesses a cost effective and less time-consuming method of resolution of claims. 

This measure creates obstacles to the formation and execution of arbitration agreements and therefore, has a disproportionate impact on arbitration versus litigation which violates the FAA and therefore preempts the anti-arbitration provisions.

Arbitration is a cost effective and expeditious process of fairly resolving disputes. SB 538, if enacted, would likely lead to many legal challenges regarding its validity, which will only result in more litigation tying up the court system and driving up litigation cost and businesses out of business.  Eliminating arbitration in health care contracts will only increase health care costs and lead to confusion, uncertainty and costly litigation for such contracts.  


STATUS: Passed Senate. Now in Assembly Health Committee.


Questions? Please contact Victor Cuauhtémoc Gomez, Sr. Director of Public Policy at

Stay in the know. Subscribe to our monthly Public Policy newsletter here.

More Posts

You Might Also Like

Press Releases
Westbank and Urban Community Announce Development Partnership
Collaboration reflects shared values and ambitions to support the future growth and success of San Jose.
Feb 13, 2020
Urban Community
Press Releases
Alaska Airlines, American Airlines announce new West Coast International Alliance
Alaska’s West Coast network to connect with American’s long-haul flying to create more choice for travelers
Feb 13, 2020
Alaska Airlines
Press Releases
Associated General Contractors of California Installs Blach Construction Chairman Mike Blach as its 2020 President
At its annual Installation and Awards Gala on Jan. 31 in San Francisco, the Associated General Contractors of California (AGC CA) installed Mike Blach, chairman of Blach Construction, as its newest president. Blach will serve a one-year term in the position. Blach Construction Project Manager Brian Azzopardi also was also sworn in as state board director.
Feb 13, 2020
Blach Construction
Press Releases
Conversation on Healthcare with Supervisor Susan Ellenberg
Press release for the SVO's Conversation on Healthcare event featuring Supervisor Susan Ellenberg and Kaiser Permanente’s Senior Vice President and Area Manager, Irene Chavez.
Dec 13, 2019
The Silicon Valley Organization
Press Releases
Broad Coalition Advocates for Reforms to Create more Market Rate and Affordable Homes
Press release for the SVO highlighting broad coalition advocates and their reform work to create more market rate and affordable homes.
Oct 29, 2019
The Silicon Valley Organization
Press Releases
SVO PAC Endorses James (Jim) Zito for San Jose City Council District 8
Press Release for the SVO PAC's endorsement of James (Jim) Zito for San Jose City Council District 8.
Oct 24, 2019
The Silicon Valley Organization
Explore ALl Posts
Follow Us

We’re on Instagram